Can James Holmes' Psychiatrist Be Held Responsible For 'The Dark Knight' Massacre?

If a psychiatrist believes her client might become violent, is she obligated to try to prevent that person from hurting people?

A Colorado court will have to answer that question now that the widow of a man killed by James Holmes has sued the alleged killer's psychiatrist.

Chantel Blunk filed the suit against psychiatrist Lynne Fenton, the University of Colorado — Denver, and five unnamed defendants , The Denver Post reported Tuesday.

Blunk's husband, Jonathan, was one of a dozen people Holmes allegedly killed during the midnight premiere of "The Dark Knight Rises" at an Aurora, Colo. movie theater last summer.

After the shooting, allegations emerged that six weeks before the massacre Fenton had declined to put Holmes under a 72-hour psychiatric hold after he told her he fantasized about killing "a lot of people."

Blunk claims Fenton was negligent because she "rejected the idea" of putting him in a hold.

"Fenton was presented with the opportunity to use ... reasonable care when the Colorado University police offered to apprehend James Holmes and place him on a psychiatric hold," the suit stated.

But Yale professor of psychiatry Dr. Howard Zonana told Business Insider that Fenton only had an obligation to commit Holmes if she believed he was an immediate threat.

"The question is whether or not she was using reasonable judgement at that point when she decided that he wasn't [a threat]," Zonana told Business Insider. Now, the court will have to examine how far into the future Fenton should have looked when trying to determine what Holmes might do, he added.

More generally, a psychiatrist's behavior with potentially violent patients is governed by a 1970s ruling from the California Supreme Court called the Tarasoff Decision.

The decision has actually been written twice. In 1974, the court said psychiatrists have the duty to warn potential victims if they believe their patients pose a threat.

A year later, however, the court ruled psychiatrists only have a duty to take steps to prevent harm but don't have a specific obligation to issue warnings to potential victims.

Most states have since adopted some variation of that decision.

Colorado statutes hold that a psychiatrist "shall not be liable for damages in any civil action for failure to warn or protect any person against a mental health patient's violent behavior, and any such person shall not be held civilly liable for failure to predict such violent behavior, except where the patient has communicated to the mental health care provider a serious threat of imminent physical violence against a specific person or persons."

DON'T MISS: James Holmes' Lawyers Hardly Spoke During His Hearing But Made These Two Revealing Statements >

More From Business Insider

Quiz: How well do you know India's economy?

Question 1

Which of these products is India the world's largest producer of?

Poll Choice Options
  • Wheat
  • Rice
  • Milk

Latest News

  • Why Herman Miller Should Have Decorated the Star Trek Set

    Watch one episode of the original Star Trek—heck, watch one minute of the show—and it's clear how much the 1960s Space Age aesthetic, one marked by Googie architecture and post-war car culture, inspired its set designers. Still, the midcentury... …

  • Motorola's New HQ Could Not Be Pinker or Sparklier

    Photo via Curbed Chicago Created by the Global Gensler firm—with maybe a few design pointers taken from some very girly middle schools—the extremely pretty new Motorola HQ is a vision of bright pink, sparkling neon signs, and quirky, interactive hangout... …

  • Catherine Deneuve Lists Resplendent French Chateau for $5.5M

    Click here to view the full photogallery. For the past few decades, when Catherine Deneuve wasn't hanging out with princes and spending time at her L.A. mansion (which, fun fact, later housed multiple ABBA members and a hippie cult),... …

  • Apple expands buybacks by $30 billion
    Apple expands buybacks by $30 billion

    Apple Inc (AAPL.O) has approved another $30 billion in share buybacks till the end of 2015 and authorized a rarely seen seven-for-one stock split, addressing calls to share more of its cash hoard while broadening the stock's appeal to individual investors. Activist investor Carl Icahn, who had famously called on the iPhone maker to boost its buyback program, tweeted his approval of the move on Wednesday. On Wednesday, Apple reported sales of 43.7 million iPhones in the quarter ended March, …

  • Eco-Friendly Prefab House Fits Together Like a 3D Puzzle

    In It's Not Easy Being Green, Curbed pulls back the curtain on cutting-edge, environmentally friendly design, from urban passive houses to green tweaks on suburban living. Have a suggestion for an upcoming column? Pass it along. Photo via Remodelista Despite... …


  • This might well be India’s biggest Ponzi scam

    It was just too good to be true. Ashok Khital, 45, displays every symptom of a man who knows he's been conned. …

  • India's star studded football league

    High and mighty including Sachin, Salman & Sun Group buy ISL teams …

  • Leaderspeak with Rajesh Janey

    Rajesh Janey, President - India & SAARC, EMC shares many firsts in his life. …

  • Power Hungry

    Gujarat has power round-the-clock. Most other states do not. Why this will matter in the general elections. …

  • Etcetera

    The most keenly watched contest of the current general election will be the one for the Varanasi parliamentary seat, where the Bharatiya Janata Party's prime ministerial hopeful Narendra Modi squares off ... …

  • Economy vs Democracy

    As the country gets election fever, cash comes out of mattresses and turns into liquor, gifts, and food. But it is not bad for the health of the economy, reports Sarika Malhotra from the trenches. …

  • Bracing for Challenges

    Raghuram Rajan is preparing to deal with concerns that may arise when a new government takes charge. …


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Gainers
    Price % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Losers
    Price % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    Recent Quotes
    Symbol Price Change % ChgChart 
    Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
    You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
  • Recent Quotes News

      Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.