Profits elude bankers to the rich in booming India



By Sumeet Chatterjee

MUMBAI (Reuters) - Ajay Piramal is just the sort of big fish every Indian private banker would love to land. With businesses from healthcare to glass and property, the 56-year-old Piramal has a net worth of $1.4 billion, according to Forbes, good for 39th on its India rich list.

The problem, at least for the swelling ranks of wealth managers in India, is that Piramal doesn't need them, putting his millions instead in his own companies and real estate ventures.

"These are only two areas I invest in, and therefore we don't need any advisor," said Piramal, who is approached by private bankers "all the time".

India may be minting millionaires, but that is failing to translate to profits for the banks that have set up teams of well-dressed, well-paid bankers to help manage those riches.

A narrow product range, rising competition, falling advisory fees and billions of dollars in wealth hidden from tax officials has stifled profits for private banks, which have aggressively ramped up operations in India.

At the same time, expenses -- mostly salaries -- are growing by as much as 20 percent a year, some in the industry say, meaning many private banks must absorb potentially heavy running costs for years before they are profitable.

The industry's difficulties in India come as more established wealth management centres in Hong Kong , Singapore and elsewhere are buffeted by poor markets.

Profit margin pressure on the sector that serves the wealthy is "partly driven by a plain vanilla product platform available for clients," said Atul Singh, head of global wealth and investment management for India at Bank of America Merrill Lynch , among the biggest players in the country.

The challenge is made greater by poor market performance, with Indian shares sliding about 17 percent this year. A spate of scandals embroiling the country's business and political elite has also soured sentiment among the rich.

The tough conditions are exacting a toll, even as many banks such as Morgan Stanley, Royal Bank of Scotland, Barclays and Bank of America Merrill Lynch continue to add staff, with an eye to the long-term potential of the fast-growing economy.

Credit Suisse , one of the largest global private banks and a player in India since 2008, is cutting its India wealth management staff by 12 people, or 20 percent, as part of a global reduction, sources said last month.

Credit Suisse is unlikely to be the last to trim staff over the medium term, industry players said.

For graphic on global wealthy population, India ranking, click

A dearth of fee-spinning alternate investment vehicles such as hedge funds and private equity, a $200,000 cap on overseas investments by onshore Indians, and an underdeveloped corporate bond market means most investments are channelled into run-of-the-mill equity products, bank deposits, and government bonds.

Investments in exotic assets such as art and wine are rare in India. Instead, the homegrown rich keep their money in real estate and gold, which doesn't require the services of polished bankers of the sort that cater to the rich in places like London, New York, Zurich and Singapore.

"When product platforms are largely undifferentiated, then prices get driven down," Singh told Reuters. "Making money is certainly tough for players in the sector, especially ones without scale."

Many tycoons like Azim Premji, chairman of No. 3 IT services exporter Wipro and the third-richest person in India, with net worth estimated by Forbes at $16.8 billion, thus prefer to use in-house staff to manage personal wealth.

In neighbouring China, wealth managers also contend with tight regulations and limited product offerings, but they also face less domestic competition. Many rich mainland Chinese invest in real estate or stash their wealth in Hong Hong or Singapore, which are thriving private banking centres.

Many of the richest Indians also have substantial wealth overseas and do their private banking in Singapore, Zurich, London or Dubai, where there are more investment options and where some banks cater specifically to non-resident Indians.


Private banks in India charge between zero and 0.5 percent advisory fees to wealthy clients, which barely covers costs for smaller players, compared to about 0.5 percent to 2 percent in more developed markets, industry insiders say.

Pressure on fees and rising costs have dragged down most wealth management firms' margins to 40-50 basis points now from 1-2 percent a few years back, they said.

The gradual shift from charging transaction-based fees to an advisory fee model, amid a global move to discourage selling of risky exotic instruments, has added to margin pressure.

"No one is making money in private banking in India," said the head of India wealth management at a U.S. bank. "Margins are so very low here because very few people want to pay money for advice and your cost of operations is going up."

To woo clients, some banks will send the adult children of entreprenuers for short training courses at U.S. universities on preserving and growing family wealth, giving them an opportunity to rub shoulders with the sons and daughters of rich Americans.

Closer to home, private banks coddle prospective and would-be customers with wine tastings and live music and dance performances by Bollywood stars.

In 2010, the population of high net worth individuals -- those with more than $1 million in investable assets -- rose nearly 21 percent in India to 153,000 -- making it the 12th largest such market, ahead of Spain and just behind Brazil, according to a report by Capgemini and Merrill Lynch .


A large chunk of Indian wealth goes undeclared. Tax authorities say billions of dollars in funds have been deposited by Indians in Swiss bank accounts and other tax havens.

A government panel in 2009 found Indian illicit funds to range between $500 billion and $1.4 trillion, which is now nearly the size of India's economy. Global Financial Integrity, a Washington-based think-tank, estimated illicit outflows of about $16 billion a year from 2002-2006.

Technology consultancy firm Cognizant said in a report that the Indian wealth management sector in the short-term would remain fragmented with a large number of brokers, financial advisors, insurance agents and tax consultants offering services.

Bank of America-Merrill Lynch, Kotak Mahindra, and HSBC were cited by Cognizant as strong players in the sector in India because of their reach, potential for cross-selling banking products and focus on domestic equities.

Big banks that have yet to take the full plunge on Indian private banking may end up looking prescient, or lucky.

UBS, a global leader in private banking, is in the early stages of providing onshore wealth management services in India.

Goldman Sachs ' private wealth management arm serves high net worth Indians from Singapore but does not have an onshore presence in India, while JPMorgan has pushed back plans to launch onshore services to late 2012, according to a source with knowledge of the situation.

Rising salaries, poaching of talent and wafer-thin margins have made it tougher for smaller home-grown wealth managers to compete with the global rivals.

However, while Western banks bring brand cachet and global expertise, they also tend to be saddled with higher costs.

"Some level of consolidation will have to happen in the next year or so. Pure broking businesses will find it difficult to continue because costs are rising and margins are under pressure," said Tashwinder Singh, head of Citi 's private bank in India.

(Editing by Tony Munroe and Michael Flaherty)


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • BSE allocates shares worth Rs 373 crore to Anchor Investors IANS - 1 hour 15 minutes ago

    Mumbai, Jan 21 (IANS) Just before the launch of its initial public offer on Monday, stock exchange major BSE allocated 4,628,158 equity shares to 'Anchor Investors' worth Rs 373 crore. The company allocated ... … More »

  • Protectionism fears remain but US, India collaboration to continue: FinMin, Industry IANS - 2 hours 37 minutes ago

    New Delhi, Jan 21 (IANS) With Donald Trump taking over the reins of the US, industry stakeholders in India and the government feel that the fears of protectionism and curbs on H1B visas will remain, but that the US will continue its financial and … More »

  • Tata Communications arm invests in Dutch firm IANS - 3 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 21 (IANS) Tata Communications Ltd's Netherlands subsidiary on Saturday announced that it has invested in Teleena Holding B.V., a mobile virtual network enabler, making it the largest investor ... … More »

  • JK Paper's Q3 net profit up 173% IANS - 5 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 21 (IANS) Branded paper company JK Paper on Saturday reported a surge of 173 per cent in its net profit for the third quarter (Q3) of 2016-17. The company's net profit stood at Rs 35.89 ... … More »

  • Globus Spirits starts commercial production in West Bengal IANS - 5 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 21 (IANS) Globus Spirits Ltd on Saturday said it started commercial production in its West Bengal unit to cater to the market of the alcohol deficit state. The production unit situated at Panagarh industrial park in Burdwan district … More »

  • Equities tumble as negative global cues spook investors IANS - 6 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 21 (IANS) After three weeks of consistent gains, key Indian equity indices were pulled lower during the trade period ended Friday due to negative global cues, broadly weak quarterly results ... … More »

  • Petrol prices cross 2013 peaks, but political opposition missing IANS - 9 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 21 (IANS) In February 2013, opposition parties, notably the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), took to the streets in protest as the price of petrol in the national capital spiralled to Rs 69.06. The BJP will not take this lying down," … More »

  • NPCI advises PhonePe App to comply with UPI guidelines IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 10:38 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 20 (IANS) The National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) on Friday directed mobile phone e-wallet PhonePe to comply with the UPI (Unified Payments Interface) guidelines. The development comes a day after the NPCI advised lending … More »

  • Railways-Jharkhand JV agreement to speed up projects IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 8:52 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 20 (IANS) The Indian Railways on Friday entered into an agreement with the state government of Jharkhand to form a joint venture (JV) company to speed up the development of railway infrastructure projects in the state. According to … More »

  • Canara Bank net soars 279% in Q3 IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 8:36 PM IST

    Bengaluru, Jan 20 (IANS) State-run Canara Bank on Friday reported a whopping 279 per cent jump in net profit of Rs 322 crore for the third quarter (October-December) of fiscal 2016-17 from Rs 85 crore ... … More »

  • Over 12,000 crore bids received for Reliance Mutual CPSE ETF IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 8:04 PM IST

    Chennai, Jan 20 (IANS) Reliance Nippon Life Asset Management (Reliance Mutual Fund) has received around Rs 12,000 crore worth of bids for the further fund offer (FFO) in Central Public Sector Enterprises Exchange Traded Fund (CPSE ETF), a top … More »

  • Cash flow to be normal soon, cut in online charges: Patel IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 8:04 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 20 (IANS) Cash flow, restricted post-demonetisation, will normalise soon but might take longer in rural and remote areas, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Urjit Patel informed a parliamentary panel on Friday. He further asserted … More »

  • Cooperative banks barred from accepting deposits under PMGKY IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 7:06 PM IST

    Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Yojana (PMGKY). "Application for the deposit in the form of Bonds Ledger Account shall be received by any banking company, other than Co-operative Banks, to which the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, applies," a Finance … More »

  • Negative global cues, disappointing results drag equities lower IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 6:04 PM IST

    Mumbai, Jan 20 (IANS) Negative global cues, along with disappointing quarterly results and a weak rupee, dragged the Indian equities markets lower on Friday. Besides, investors remained cautious ahead ... … More »

  • Adani Power Q3 consolidated net loss at Rs 325 cr IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 5:26 PM IST

    Mumbai/Ahmedabad, Jan 20 (IANS) Private power producer Adani Power on Friday reported a consolidated net loss of Rs 325.27 crore for the quarter ended December 31, 2016. The country's largest private thermal power producer had reported a net profit … More »

  • Motherson Sumi launches $600 mn open offer for Finnish PKC Group IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 4:52 PM IST

    Mumbai, Jan 20 (IANS) Specialised automotive component manufacturer Motherson Sumi Systems (MSSL) has launched a bid to acquire Finland-based wiring harness major PKC Group through an open offer worth Euro 571 million (more than $600 million or more … More »

  • Negative global cues drag equities lower IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 4:42 PM IST

    Mumbai, Jan 20 (IANS) Negative global cues, along with profit booking and a weak rupee, dragged the Indian equities markets lower on Friday. Besides, investors remained cautious ahead of US President-elect ... … More »

  • Microsoft launches 'Azure Analysis Services' IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 1:52 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 20 (IANS) Microsoft on Friday announced the public preview of 'Azure Analysis Services', a latest addition to company's Cloud platform to simplify data analysis. Azure Analysis Services ... … More »

  • 'Teavana' to double tea sales in India: Tata Starbucks IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 1:50 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 20 (IANS) With its coffee beverage business already at peak, global coffeehouse chain Tata Starbucks aims to double tea beverage sales with the launch of its global flagship tea brand "Teavana" in the country, says the company's chief … More »

  • Profit booking drags Indian equities lower IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 1:44 PM IST

    Mumbai, Jan 20 (IANS) Profit booking, coupled with negative global cues and a weak rupee, dragged the Indian equities markets lower during the mid-afternoon trade session on Friday. Besides, investors ... … More »

  • 8 Warren Buffet quotes and how you can use them Simplus Information Services - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 12:13 PM IST

    America is home to many leading lights in various fields. One such notable person is Warren Edward Buffet. Warren Buffet is a famous business tycoon and a philanthropist. He is often featured in lists of the world’s wealthiest people. His finances … More »

  • Budget 2017: 10 things that would provide relief from demonetisation Simplus Information Services - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 11:55 AM IST

    Finance minister Arun Jaitley will make the budget speech in the Lok Sabha on 1 February 2017. In the backdrop of demonetisation, there is a general anticipation of lower taxes. The government may try to thank the people for putting up with … More »

  • Selling pressure pulls equities lower IANS - Fri 20 Jan, 2017 10:24 AM IST

    Mumbai, Jan 20 (IANS) Indian equities markets trade on a negative note during the early morning trade session on Friday, as heavy selling pressure was witnessed in banking and IT stocks. The wider 51-scrip ... … More »

  • Banks told to report deposits over Rs 10 lakh a year IANS - Thu 19 Jan, 2017 10:44 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 19 (IANS) In yet another measure related to the recent demonetisation, the government has asked banks to report deposits in any account aggregating Rs 10 lakh in a year, as well as cash payments of Rs 1 lakh or more on credit card … More »

  • CCI imposes penalties on 7 cement companies for bid-rigging IANS - Thu 19 Jan, 2017 10:16 PM IST

    New Delhi, Jan 19 (IANS) Fair play regulator Competition Commission of India (CCI) on Thursday said it has imposed penalties on seven cement companies for bid-rigging. "The bid-rigging has been established from quoting of unusually higher rates in … More »


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Gainers
    Price % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Losers
    Price % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    Recent Quotes
    Symbol Price Change % ChgChart 
    Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
    You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
  • Recent Quotes News

      Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

    Yahoo Cricket