3 Holes in Mitt Romney's Tax Plan

Mitt Romney likes to say that if he were running a company and somebody presented him with a cockamamie idea--like the half-baked schemes that fly around Washington all the time--he'd fire the offending lackey.

But Romney might be the one out on the street if his new tax plan had to pass through corporate accounting.

[See 3 myths about Mitt Romney and the rich.]

Romney has freshened his plan for reviving the economy with a new call to lower the tax rates everybody pays, along with cuts in corporate tax rates and other reforms that he has already proposed. Romney wants to lower the current rates on personal income by 20 percent, in every bracket, which means the lowest rate would fall to 8 percent and the highest would fall to 28 percent.

Romney invokes the familiar, if dubious, supply-side argument that lower taxes will make the economy grow faster and help create more jobs. In theory, that would bring in more tax revenue to help offset the revenue the government would lose by lowering taxes. Romney also says he'd make deep cuts in federal spending, so that the government needs less money in the first place.

It's a pleasing idea. But Romney must be hoping that nobody with a calculator is paying attention, because cutting taxes so abruptly, at a time when the U.S. government is severely in debt, would either push Washington's annual deficits to new heights or force draconian cuts in services that many Americans depend on. Here are three specific problems with Romney's tax plan:

It would make the national debt far worse. Robertson Williams of the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center estimates that cutting tax rates by 20 percent would reduce government revenue by about $200 billion per year. So at a time when the nation needs to start paying down its debt, Romney's move would send the national debt in the other direction.

[Check out U.S. News Weekly: An insider's guide to politics and policy.]

Conservatives who claim that lower taxes boost economic growth have a high hurdle to clear, since George W. Bush basically followed that script with the tax cuts he signed into law in 2001 and 2003. The result was real economic growth, after inflation, that averaged a measly 1.4 percent per year between 2001 and 2009. Even if you factor out the recession year of 2009, growth averaged just 2 percent. From 1980 through 2000, by contrast, real GDP growth averaged 3.2 percent per year, including three recessionary years in which real growth was negative. So there's no evidence that the lower tax rates of the last decade have helped boost economic growth.

They've sure added to the national debt, however. The Bush administration ran a deficit every year after Bush first started cutting taxes, following four years when Washington ran a surplus. Overall, the Bush-era budgets added about $3.5 trillion to the national debt. President Obama will have added to the debt by another $4.8 trillion or so by the end of his first term, which is certainly no endorsement of Obama's economic policies. But any proposal to cut taxes further without first addressing the debt simply ignores the real-world evidence on how lower taxes affect the government's ledgers.

[See why raising taxes on the rich is so hard.]

It would require much bigger spending cuts than Romney has acknowledged. In a Wall Street Journal op-ed explaining his tax plan, Romney said he'd make "deep cuts in federal spending" that he has "previously outlined." Well, he may have outlined those cuts, but he hasn't detailed whose programs or benefits would get the ax. That conveniently allows Romney to ignore the intense political pushback that would most likely make deep cuts in federal spending extremely difficult or impossible.

Here's what Romney has said: He'd cap federal spending at 20 percent of GDP by the end of 2016; he'd put a floor on defense spending, which would most likely translate into more spending on national security, not less; and at some point, he'd balance the budget. Again, it sounds nice, but running the numbers yields scenarios so alarming as to be implausible.

If Romney's spending cap applied to all federal programs except defense, then government spending on everything--including Medicare and Social Security--would have to fall by about 20 percent, according to analysis by the left-leaning Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. If Medicare and Social Security were fenced off, then "nondiscretionary" programs that provide funding for roads, NASA, education, foreign aid, health, workplace safety, environmental protection, and many other things would have to be cut by an average of 38 percent. The cuts would be even deeper if Romney insisted on a balanced budget at any point over the next decade.

[See why Herman Cain--and 9-9-9--are back.]

Americans may like the idea of smaller government in general, but there would most likely be a nationwide revolt if funding for hundreds of programs that provide services and improve living standards for millions of Americans were suddenly cut. Maybe that's why Romney's willing to outline his cuts, but not willing to offer specifics.

It would favor the rich. Romney's tax plan makes him even more vulnerable to charges of aristocratic elitism. It would lower tax rates for the highest earners by seven percentage points, for example, while only lowering rates for the lowest earners by two points. It would also leave intact the 15 percent tax rate on capital gains and other types of investment income, which allows the superwealthy--including Romney himself--to pay lower tax rates than many middle-class workers, since wages for most people are taxed at higher rates.

Romney has demonstrated a tin ear before, and his tax plan adds to the impression that he's out of touch with the inclinations of ordinary Americans. Polls consistently show, for instance, that a majority of Americans support higher taxes on the wealthy. The release of Romney's own returns, which show that his tax rate is a mere 14 percent or so, has intensified the belief that the tax code favors the rich.

[See why the GOP has a Gloomy-Gus problem.]

To even things out, Romney says he'd limit certain tax deductions for the wealthy, though he hasn't said which deductions. And he'd eliminate the capital gains tax completely for people with less than $200,000 in income. But that's likely to bring little comfort to the majority of middle-class workers who rarely have a capital gain to report.

If elected, perhaps Romney would flesh out the deep spending cuts and other unpopular measures that would be required to make his tax plan work. But for now, the wealthiest candidate in the race seems to be testing just how gullible voters really are, with an incomplete proposal that he himself would probably reject if politics were anything like business.

Rick Newman is the author of Rebounders: How Winners Pivot From Setback to Success, to be published in May. Follow him on Twitter: @rickjnewman

More From US News & World Report


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • Mistry replies on Tata Sons' 'counter-allegations' IANS - 6 hours ago

    The replies came through an affidavit which was filed by Mistry's investment companies to the NCLT's Mumbai bench. The rejoinder comes after Tata Sons had filed an over 200-page affidavit with the NCLT earlier in January, rebutting charges levelled … More »

  • Software to comply with Indian labour laws unveiled IANS - 6 hours ago

    "The SaaS-based plug-and-play tool gives free access to 40,000 pages of the Indian labour laws for compliance management by enterprises, factories, shops and businesses in the country," said Simpliance Founder Anil D'Souza. "Labour law compliance … More »

  • 50% of BSE IPO subscribed on 1st day of offering IANS - 8 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Stock exchange major BSE's initial public offering (IPO) was subscribed by 50 per cent on the first day of the Rs 1,243.43 offering which started on Monday. According to the data ... … More »

  • Note ban boosts deposits, lowers bank loan growth: Report IANS - 8 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) The recent demonetisation in India led to an immediate jump in current account and savings account (CASA) deposits, incremental lending saw a massive drop, while digital banking witnessed a major surge, a report said on … More »

  • Okinawa Autotech launches e-scooter Ridge IANS - 8 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) Electric two-wheeler manufacturer Okinawa Scooters on Monday launched its first offering in the Indian market an e-scooter -- Ridge -- priced at Rs 43,702 (Ex-showroom, Delhi). ... … More »

  • Differential impact of demonetisation across ABS transactions: Ind-Ra IANS - 8 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Credit ratings agency India Ratings and Research (Ind-Ra) on Monday said it has observed differential impact of demonetisation across asset-backed securities (ABS) transactions. According to the agency's report -- Indian ABS … More »

  • India against EU, Canada-proposed dispute settlement at WTO IANS - 9 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) India has opposed an informal proposal by the EU and Canada for a global investment pact with an investor-to-state dispute settlement (ISDS) mechanism at the WTO by which corporates can take governments to international … More »

  • EIH's Q3 net profit up 8.29% IANS - 9 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Hospitality major EIH on Monday reported a rise of 8.29 per cent in its stand alone net profit for the third quarter (Q3) of 2016-17. The company which was formerly known as the 'East ... … More »

  • Asian Paints net profit up, hit by demonetisation IANS - 9 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Paints major Asian Paints on Monday posted a marginal 1.5 per cent rise in consolidated net profit to Rs 489.31 crore in the quarter ended December 31, as compared to Rs 482.02 crore ... … More »

  • SBI calls for raising income tax exemption limits IANS - 10 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Presenting an agenda for the forthcoming Union Budget at a time when banks are flush with funds post-demonetisation, state-run SBI on Monday called for raising various income tax ... … More »

  • Bharti Infratel's Q3 net up 25% IANS - 11 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) Telecom tower infrastructure services provider Bharti Infratel's consolidated net profit went up 25 per cent in the third quarter of 2016-17, the company said on Monday. The company posted a net profit of Rs 620 crore for … More »

  • Budgetary expectations lift Indian equities IANS - 11 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Hopes of budgetary incentives and healthy buying in metal, automobile and oil and gas sectors lifted the Indian equities markets on Monday. However, profit booking at higher levels ... … More »

  • FRBM Committee submits report on fiscal consolidation roadmap IANS - 11 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Committee, headed by former Revenue and Expenditure Secretary N.K. Singh, submitted its report to Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on Monday with recommendations on the … More »

  • NEXTracker, CleanMax Solar to set up tracker system in Chennai IANS - 12 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) American solar solutions provider NEXTracker announced on Monday that it is partnering with India's CleanMax Solar to supply a 30 MW solar tracker system to a project in Tamil Nadu. "NEXTracker has partnered with CleanMax … More »

  • HUL's net profit up 7% in Q3 IANS - 12 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) FMCG major Hindustan Unilever on Monday reported a seven per cent increase in its net profit to Rs 1,037.93 crore in the quarter ended December 31, 2016 as compared to Rs 971.66 crore in the corresponding quarter last fiscal … More »

  • Strong rupee, budgetary expectations lift equities IANS - 14 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Rupee appreciation, coupled with hopes of positive incentives in the upcoming Union Budget and broadly positive Asian indices, lifted the Indian equities markets on Monday. The key ... … More »

  • Global semiconductor revenue to grow 7.2% in 2017: Gartner IANS - 15 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Worldwide semiconductor revenue is set to hit $364.1 billion in 2017, an increase of 7.2 per cent from 2016, representing a turnaround for the industry as it experienced 1.5 per cent growth in 2016, market research firm Gartner … More »

  • itel unveils 4G VoLTE-enabled smartphone at Rs 7,550 IANS - 15 hours ago

    New Delhi, Jan 23 (IANS) itel Mobile, part of Chinese mobile manufacturer Transsion Holdings, on Monday launched a new it1518 4G VoLTE-enabled smartphone at Rs 7,550. The 5-inch device houses 8MP rear ... … More »

  • Indian equities buoy on strong rupee, budgetary expectations IANS - 16 hours ago

    Mumbai, Jan 23 (IANS) Indian equities markets traded on a flat-to-positive note during the mid-afternoon trade session on Monday, as rupee appreciation, coupled with hopes of positive incentives in the ... … More »

  • Amazon India to empower Naga women entrepreneurs IANS - 16 hours ago

    Bengaluru, Jan 23 (IANS) With a view to drive digital literacy among women entrepreneurs in Nagaland, Amazon India on Monday partnered with the state government and the National Skill Development Corp (NSDC) to provide them a global platform to sell … More »

  • 5 reasons you should bother about Budget 2017 Simplus Information Services - 18 hours ago

    The government reveals the income and expenditure incurred in the year gone by. It is the estimate that the government makes about the income and expenditure for the year ahead. The government announced the demonetization of currency notes in … More »

  • Is digitisation the need of the hour? Simplus Information Services - 18 hours ago

    What makes digitisation or digitalisation so important? The conversion of data from analogue to digital has been going on since the 1950s. Nowadays, digital technology is helping restructure businesses, organisations, and economies. … More »

  • Coal India discontinues Forward e-auction Scheme 2007 IANS - Sun 22 Jan, 2017 7:12 PM IST

    Kolkata, Jan 22 (IANS) Following special forward e-auction for power sector and exclusive e-auction for non-power consumers being conducted in a "regular manner", Coal India Ltd (CIL) has advised its subsidiaries to stop conducting the Forward … More »

  • Kudankulam Unit 2 generates full capacity of 1,000 MW IANS - Sun 22 Jan, 2017 7:08 PM IST

    Chennai, Jan 22 (IANS) The second 1,000 MW atomic power reactor at the Kundankulam Nuclear Power Project (KNPP) in Tamil Nadu has attained its maximum capacity, the Russian builders announced on Sunday. "Kudankulam NPP Unit No 2 has for the first … More »

  • Non-life insurers' premium income grows over 25% in December IANS - Sun 22 Jan, 2017 5:04 PM IST

    Kolkata, Jan 22 (IANS) Non-life insurance companies posted over 25 per cent increase in their gross premium income (direct premium income underwritten) to Rs 9,760.23 crore in December compared to Rs 7,777.38 ... … More »


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Gainers
    Price % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Price % Losers
    Price % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    Recent Quotes
    Symbol Price Change % ChgChart 
    Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
    You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
  • Recent Quotes News

      Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.